Daily Reading Practice

Day 8 of 10
Grade 4 ELA | Author's Claim & Evidence | Part A/Part B Format
FL B.E.S.T. Standard: ELA.4.R.2.4 - Explain an author's claim and the reasons and evidence used to support the claim.
IXL Skills: Identify supporting details; Identify an author's claim
/4
Directions: Read the passage below carefully. Then answer the questions that follow. Identify the author's main claim and the evidence used to support it.
Homework Should Be Shorter

Many parents and teachers believe that more homework means better learning. However, research tells a different story. For elementary school students, shorter homework assignments are more effective than long ones.

Studies by education researchers at Duke University found that homework has limited benefits for students in grades K through 6. When students spend more than 30 minutes on homework each night, they do not perform any better in school. In fact, too much homework can actually hurt younger students by causing stress and reducing their interest in learning.

Dr. Harris Cooper, who has studied homework for over 20 years, recommends the "10-minute rule." According to this guideline, students should have about 10 minutes of homework per grade level. That means a fourth-grader should have no more than 40 minutes of homework per night.

Children also need time for other important activities. Playing outside, reading for pleasure, and spending time with family all contribute to healthy development. When homework takes up the entire evening, students miss out on these valuable experiences.

Some people argue that homework teaches responsibility. While this may be true, responsibility can be learned through shorter, more focused assignments. Quality matters more than quantity when it comes to homework.

Schools should reconsider their homework policies. By assigning less homework, teachers can help students learn more effectively while protecting their well-being.

Questions 1-2: Author's Claim
This question has two parts. First, answer Part A. Then, answer Part B.
Part A
What is the author's MAIN CLAIM in this passage?
A
Homework should be completely eliminated from schools.
B
Elementary students benefit more from shorter homework assignments than longer ones.
C
Teachers do not understand how to assign homework properly.
D
Playing outside is more important than doing homework.
Part B
Which piece of evidence from the passage BEST supports the author's claim?
A
"Many parents and teachers believe that more homework means better learning."
B
"Some people argue that homework teaches responsibility."
C
"When students spend more than 30 minutes on homework each night, they do not perform any better in school."
D
"Quality matters more than quantity when it comes to homework."
Questions 3-4: Reasons and Evidence
This question has two parts. First, answer Part A. Then, answer Part B.
Part A
According to the passage, why is too much homework harmful for young students?
A
It makes them perform worse on tests than students with no homework.
B
It causes stress and reduces their interest in learning.
C
It takes away time from watching television.
D
It makes teachers work harder to grade assignments.
Part B
Why does the author mention Dr. Harris Cooper and Duke University?
A
To show that the claim is based on expert research, not just opinion
B
To prove that universities give too much homework
C
To explain where the "10-minute rule" originated
D
To describe the history of homework in America
Back to Daily Reading

Answer Key (Teacher Reference)

Question 1 Part A: B - Elementary students benefit more from shorter homework assignments than longer ones.
This captures the author's central argument that shorter, not longer, homework is better.
Question 1 Part B: C - "When students spend more than 30 minutes on homework each night, they do not perform any better in school."
This research finding directly supports the claim that longer homework is not more effective.
Question 2 Part A: B - It causes stress and reduces their interest in learning.
Paragraph 2 explicitly states these negative effects of too much homework.
Question 2 Part B: A - To show that the claim is based on expert research, not just opinion
Citing researchers and universities adds credibility and shows the argument is evidence-based.