FAST Practice Quiz

Compare and Contrast
Grade 5 Reading
FL B.E.S.T. Standard: ELA.5.R.1.3
10 Questions
/10
Directions: Read both passages carefully. Then answer the questions comparing and contrasting the characters, settings, and events. Use evidence from both texts to support your answers.
Passage 1: The River's Edge

Kai grew up on a houseboat on the Mississippi River. Every morning, he woke to the gentle rocking of the water and the calls of herons flying overhead. His father was a river guide, and Kai had learned to read the currents before he learned to read books.

At school, Kai struggled. The classroom felt like a cage - no windows that opened, no fresh air, no freedom. He couldn't sit still for long. His grades were average at best. But on the river, Kai transformed. He could navigate blindfolded through the sandbars. He knew every fishing spot within fifty miles.

"You're smart in ways school doesn't measure," his father told him. "The river is your classroom."

When a group of tourists got stranded on a sandbar during a storm, it was twelve-year-old Kai who guided the rescue boat through the treacherous water. The newspaper called him a hero. Kai just shrugged. "I know the river," he said simply. "It's what I'm good at."

Passage 2: The Library Corner

Nina lived in a small apartment in Chicago with her grandmother. The apartment was cramped and noisy - sirens all night, neighbors shouting, her little cousins always running around. The only quiet place Nina could find was the public library three blocks away.

Every day after school, Nina claimed her favorite corner by the window. She devoured books like food - fiction, history, science, everything. At school, Nina was the top student in every subject. Teachers praised her essays, and she won the district spelling bee twice.

But Nina felt awkward in real life. She didn't know how to talk to other kids. Sports confused her, and she always got picked last for teams. At recess, she usually sat alone, reading.

"You're smart in ways that will take you far," her grandmother told her. "Books are your wings."

When the library needed a student volunteer to help younger kids with reading, Nina hesitated - talking to strangers was hard. But surrounded by books, she felt brave. By the end of the year, she had helped twenty kids improve their reading levels, and for the first time, she had made real friends.

1
What is the MAIN similarity between Kai and Nina?
A
Both live with single parents.
B
Both are strong in some areas but struggle in others.
C
Both prefer to be alone all the time.
D
Both dislike school entirely.
2
How do the SETTINGS contrast in these passages?
A
Kai lives in a quiet, natural environment while Nina lives in a crowded, noisy city.
B
Both characters live in peaceful, rural settings.
C
Kai lives in a city while Nina lives by the river.
D
The settings are essentially the same.
3
Which sentence BEST compares what Kai's father and Nina's grandmother say to them?
A
Both adults criticize the children for not being well-rounded.
B
Both adults encourage the children by recognizing their unique strengths.
C
Kai's father wants him to do better in school, but Nina's grandmother doesn't care about education.
D
Nina's grandmother gives advice, but Kai's father does not.
4
How are Kai's and Nina's CHALLENGES different?
A
Kai struggles academically but excels physically; Nina excels academically but struggles socially.
B
Both struggle with making friends.
C
Kai is good at everything while Nina struggles with everything.
D
Nina's challenges are more serious than Kai's.
5
Compare how both characters are recognized for their strengths by the end of their stories.
A
Both are recognized only by their families.
B
Kai is called a hero in the newspaper; Nina helps other kids and makes friends.
C
Neither character is recognized for their strengths.
D
Only Kai receives recognition while Nina remains unknown.
6
What is a THEME that both passages share?
A
Academic success is the most important kind of success.
B
Everyone has unique strengths, even if they don't fit traditional measures of success.
C
Rural life is better than city life.
D
Children should only focus on what they're naturally good at.
7
In what way do the passages present CONTRASTING types of intelligence?
A
Kai shows practical, hands-on intelligence while Nina shows academic, book-based intelligence.
B
Both characters demonstrate the same type of intelligence.
C
Kai is intelligent but Nina is not.
D
The passages do not discuss intelligence.
8
Both Kai and Nina find a place where they feel confident. Compare these special places and explain what they have in common.
A
Both the river and the library allow the characters to use their natural talents and feel competent.
B
Both places are outside of the city.
C
Both places are where the characters feel uncomfortable.
D
The river and library have nothing in common.
9
Write a paragraph comparing and contrasting Kai and Nina. Include at least TWO similarities and TWO differences. Use signal words and text evidence.
10
How do the two passages work together to develop the theme that "there are many kinds of intelligence"? Use evidence from BOTH passages.
___Multiple Choice (8)
___Written Response (2)
___Total (10)