Why I Stopped Taking Behavior Personally (And You Should Too)
Last Tuesday, little Marcus (not my son, my student Marcus) looked me dead in the eye and said, "This is stupid and I hate math!" Then he swept his worksheet off his desk and crossed his arms.
Five years ago, that would have ruined my entire day. I would have gone home to Carlos complaining about disrespectful kids and questioning whether I was cut out for this job. But last Tuesday? I just nodded and said, "Sounds like you're having a really hard time right now. Want to tell me what's going on?"
Turns out his parents had been fighting all morning and he hadn't eaten breakfast. Suddenly, his outburst made perfect sense.
The Day Everything Changed
I wish I could say I learned this lesson gracefully, but ay, that's not how it happened. About seven years into my career, I had a student named Isabella who seemed determined to make my life miserable. She would roll her eyes at everything I said, "forget" her homework daily, and had perfected the art of passive-aggressive sighing.
I took it so personally. I was convinced she just didn't like me, that I was failing as a teacher, that maybe I should have listened to my mother and become a nurse instead.
Then one day, Isabella's grandmother came to pick her up early. She pulled me aside and quietly explained that Isabella's mom had just been deployed overseas. This little girl was angry at the world, not at me.
That conversation changed everything.
What "Not Taking It Personally" Really Means
Here's what I wish someone had told me in my first year: when kids act out, it's rarely about you. I mean, really rarely.
That student who won't follow directions? Maybe they're hungry. The one who seems defiant? Could be they didn't understand and are too embarrassed to ask. The kid who's suddenly withdrawn? Something might be happening at home that they can't even put into words.
This doesn't mean we excuse bad behavior or lower our expectations. It means we respond from a place of curiosity instead of defensiveness.
The Questions That Changed My Classroom
Instead of thinking "Why is this child being difficult?" I started asking myself different questions:
What need might this behavior be meeting? Sometimes kids act out because it's the only way they know how to get attention, even negative attention.
What's happening in this child's world right now? A divorce, a new baby, a grandparent in the hospital, parents working three jobs. Our kids carry so much.
How can I help this child feel safe and successful? Because that's really what most behavior issues come down to. Kids who feel safe and capable rarely act out.
What would I want someone to assume about my own child if they were struggling? This one hits different when you're a parent too.
Practical Strategies That Actually Work
Start with connection before correction. When a student is having a rough day, I try to find a moment to check in privately. "Hey, I noticed you seem frustrated today. Everything okay?" Sometimes that's all it takes.
Look for patterns. Is the behavior happening at the same time every day? After specials? Before lunch? Right after a transition? Patterns tell us so much about what's really going on.
Assume positive intent. Maybe they're not trying to disrupt your lesson. Maybe they're just excited about what you're teaching. Maybe they're trying to help a friend. Start there.
Remember the iceberg. What you're seeing (the behavior) is just the tip. There's so much more underneath that you can't see.
When I Still Struggle
Let me be real with you. I still have days when a student's behavior gets under my skin. Last month, I had a kid who kept making jokes during our reading lesson, and by the third interruption, I was irritated.
But now I have tools. I paused, took a breath, and realized he was probably nervous about reading aloud. So instead of getting frustrated, I gave him a different way to participate. Problem solved.
The difference is that now I catch myself faster. Instead of spiraling into "this kid doesn't respect me," I can step back and think, "What's really going on here?"
The Ripple Effect
Here's what nobody tells you about this mindset shift: it doesn't just change how you handle difficult moments. It changes your entire classroom culture.
When kids see that you respond to their struggles with curiosity instead of judgment, they start opening up. They tell you when they're having a hard time instead of acting out. They become more honest about what they need.
My students know they can come to me and say, "Mrs. Santos, I'm having a really bad day," and I'll work with them. That trust? It's everything.
For My Fellow Perfectionists
If you're like me and tend to take everything personally, here's your permission slip to stop. You are not responsible for fixing every problem in your students' lives. You're not supposed to be perfect, and neither are they.
Your job is to create a safe space where learning can happen, to meet kids where they are, and to help them grow. Some days that looks like teaching fractions. Other days it looks like helping a child process their emotions so they can be ready to learn.
Both are equally important.
Moving Forward
Tomorrow, when a student tests your patience (and they will, porque that's what kids do), try to pause before you react. Ask yourself what might be driving that behavior. Look for the need underneath the action.
Remember that hurt people hurt people, but loved people love people. Our kids need us to see past their worst moments and believe in their best selves.
We're not just teaching subjects, mijas. We're teaching human beings who are still figuring out how to be in this world. Let's give them the grace we'd want for our own children.
What behavior challenge are you facing right now? I bet if we put our heads together, we can figure out what that child really needs.
Maria Santos
Maria has been teaching 4th grade in Tampa, Florida for 22 years. Known as "the math whisperer" among her colleagues, she writes about the real challenges and victories of teaching in Florida's public schools.
When she's not grading papers or creating lesson plans, you can find Maria at her local teacher supply store (with coupons in hand) or sharing teaching tips over cafecito with her teacher friends.
View Full Profile →Related Articles
The Calm Corner: Worth the Classroom Real Estate
Classroom management tip: Last Tuesday, I watched Miguel transform from a hurricane of frustration i...
The January Struggle is Real: Getting Your Classroom Back on Track After Winter Break
Classroom management tip: Last Tuesday, little Marcus (not my son, my student Marcus) raised his han...
Ready to Improve Your FAST Scores?
Upload your class data and get personalized IXL success plans in seconds.
Try It Free