Daily Reading Practice

Day 10 of 10
Grade 5 ELA | Compare Accounts | Part A/Part B Format
FL B.E.S.T. Standard: ELA.5.R.3.3 - Compare and contrast accounts of the same event or topic.
IXL Skills: Compare information from two texts, Analyze multiple accounts
/4
Directions: Read BOTH passages below carefully. Then answer the questions that follow. Pay attention to how the two accounts are similar and different.
Two Views on Space Exploration
Passage A: From a Science Magazine Article

Space exploration represents one of humanity's greatest achievements. Since the first satellite launch in 1957, space programs have produced countless benefits for life on Earth. Weather satellites help us predict dangerous storms, saving thousands of lives annually. GPS technology, originally developed for spacecraft, now guides everything from ambulances to delivery trucks. Medical advances from space research include improved heart monitors and water purification systems used in developing countries.

Critics argue that space programs are too expensive, but the return on investment is substantial. NASA estimates that for every dollar spent on space exploration, approximately seven to fourteen dollars are generated in the economy through new technologies and industries.

Passage B: From a Community Newsletter Editorial

While space missions make exciting headlines, we must question whether billions of dollars should be spent looking at distant planets when so many problems exist right here at home. Schools lack funding for basic supplies, roads crumble from neglect, and millions of people struggle to afford healthcare. These immediate needs should take priority over exploring places humans may never visit.

Supporters of space programs point to technological benefits, but many of these same innovations could be developed through direct research at a fraction of the cost. Rather than spending money to send robots to Mars, we could invest in research that directly addresses climate change, disease, and poverty. Our first responsibility is to the people living on Earth today.

Questions 1-2: Comparing Accounts
This question has two parts. First, answer Part A. Then, answer Part B.
Part A
How do the two passages differ in their perspective on space exploration?
A
Passage A discusses Mars exploration, while Passage B focuses on moon missions.
B
Passage A was written by scientists, while Passage B was written by astronauts.
C
Passage A argues space exploration is unnecessary, while Passage B supports it.
D
Passage A emphasizes the benefits of space exploration, while Passage B argues that the money should be spent on Earth-based problems.
Part B
Which pair of sentences BEST shows the contrasting viewpoints of the two passages?
A
Passage A: "Since the first satellite launch in 1957..." / Passage B: "While space missions make exciting headlines..."
B
Passage A: "Weather satellites help us predict dangerous storms..." / Passage B: "Schools lack funding for basic supplies..."
C
Passage A: "The return on investment is substantial." / Passage B: "These immediate needs should take priority."
D
Passage A: "GPS technology...now guides everything from ambulances to delivery trucks." / Passage B: "Supporters of space programs point to technological benefits."
Questions 3-4: Analyzing Multiple Accounts
This question has two parts. First, answer Part A. Then, answer Part B.
Part A
What do BOTH passages acknowledge about space exploration?
A
Space programs are too expensive for any country to afford.
B
Space programs have led to technological benefits.
C
Humans should focus on traveling to Mars immediately.
D
Weather satellites are the most important achievement of space exploration.
Part B
Which detail from Passage B shows the author acknowledges what Passage A emphasizes?
A
"Supporters of space programs point to technological benefits..."
B
"Schools lack funding for basic supplies, roads crumble from neglect..."
C
"Rather than spending money to send robots to Mars..."
D
"Our first responsibility is to the people living on Earth today."
Back to Daily Reading

Answer Key (Teacher Reference)

Question 1 Part A: D - Passage A emphasizes the benefits of space exploration, while Passage B argues that the money should be spent on Earth-based problems.
This captures the central contrast between the two passages' perspectives.
Question 1 Part B: C - Passage A: "The return on investment is substantial." / Passage B: "These immediate needs should take priority."
These directly contrasting statements show the core disagreement about priorities.
Question 2 Part A: B - Space programs have led to technological benefits.
Both passages mention technological benefits, though they differ on whether these justify the cost.
Question 2 Part B: A - "Supporters of space programs point to technological benefits..."
This shows Passage B acknowledging the benefits argument that Passage A emphasizes.