Daily Reading Practice

Day 8 of 10
Grade 7 ELA | Claims & Evidence | Part A/Part B Format
FL B.E.S.T. Standard: ELA.7.R.2.4 - Track the development of an argument, analyzing the types of reasoning and evidence used.
IXL Skills: Identify claims and evidence, Evaluate argument strength
/4
Directions: Read the passage below carefully. Then answer the questions that follow. Identify the author's main claim and evaluate how effectively the evidence supports the argument.
The Benefits of Year-Round Schooling

Traditional school calendars are outdated relics of an agricultural past that no longer serves American students. Schools should transition to year-round schedules to maximize learning outcomes and better prepare students for the modern world.

The most compelling argument for year-round schooling is the prevention of "summer slide," the documented loss of academic skills during extended breaks. Research from Johns Hopkins University found that students lose an average of two months of mathematical computation skills over summer vacation. For students from lower-income families, the losses in reading achievement are even more pronounced. By distributing breaks throughout the year instead of concentrating them in summer, year-round schools dramatically reduce this learning loss.

Additionally, year-round schooling addresses chronic overcrowding in many districts. Schools operating on multiple tracks can accommodate significantly more students in the same building. In Los Angeles, year-round scheduling allowed the district to serve 30% more students without building new facilities, saving taxpayers millions of dollars.

Critics often claim that year-round schooling disrupts family vacations and summer programs. However, year-round schools still provide the same total number of vacation days; they're simply distributed differently. Many families report that shorter, more frequent breaks are actually preferable for preventing burnout and maintaining work-life balance.

With mounting evidence of academic benefits and practical advantages, the case for year-round schooling is compelling. Districts that continue clinging to the traditional calendar are prioritizing nostalgia over student success.

Questions 1-2: Claims and Evidence
This question has two parts. First, answer Part A. Then, answer Part B.
Part A
What is the author's MAIN CLAIM in this passage?
A
Summer vacation causes students to lose academic skills.
B
Schools should adopt year-round schedules to improve learning outcomes.
C
Year-round schooling saves money by reducing the need for new buildings.
D
Traditional school calendars were designed for agricultural communities.
Part B
Which type of evidence does the author use MOST effectively to support the main claim?
A
Personal anecdotes from students who attend year-round schools
B
Research data and specific examples from schools and districts
C
Expert opinions from education professors
D
Historical information about the origins of traditional school calendars
Questions 3-4: Evaluating Arguments
This question has two parts. First, answer Part A. Then, answer Part B.
Part A
How does the author address the counterargument about family vacations in paragraph 4?
A
By admitting that year-round schooling does make family vacations impossible
B
By explaining that vacation days are redistributed, not reduced
C
By ignoring the concern entirely
D
By arguing that family vacations are unimportant
Part B
Which phrase from the passage contains language that reveals BIAS rather than objective analysis?
A
"Research from Johns Hopkins University found that students lose an average of two months"
B
"Year-round schools still provide the same total number of vacation days"
C
"Districts that continue clinging to the traditional calendar are prioritizing nostalgia over student success"
D
"In Los Angeles, year-round scheduling allowed the district to serve 30% more students"
Back to Daily Reading

Answer Key (Teacher Reference)

Question 1 Part A: B - Schools should adopt year-round schedules to improve learning outcomes.
This is the central argument; other options are supporting points or background.
Question 1 Part B: B - Research data and specific examples from schools and districts
The author cites Johns Hopkins research and Los Angeles district data as primary evidence.
Question 2 Part A: B - By explaining that vacation days are redistributed, not reduced
The author directly addresses the concern by clarifying that total vacation time remains the same.
Question 2 Part B: C - "Districts that continue clinging to the traditional calendar are prioritizing nostalgia over student success"
"Clinging" and the framing of opposing views as "nostalgia" reveal bias rather than objective reporting.